The Star Forge vs Malachor V

[Darth Osiris]

The music to Malachor was good, but that is about it. I really don't notice the music on the star forge (I have other stuff playing over it), but the main reason the star forge is the best is the buid-up to saving Bastila and taking on Malak, and then an ending which doesn't make you think 'well, that was pretty pointless'. When I first completed Malachor, I was getting ready to activate every possible stimulant for my character, expecting a really big battle, then the credits came on. And then, on the second playthrough, it turned out I had a dodgy disk. Irrelevant, I know, but a pathetic ending coupled with having to try and get a replacement disk (They really don't make it easy) really annoyed me.

[Lord Mayyn]

thats a hard decision.

 

the star forge was powerful. so much power in that machine. enough to take over the galaxy. you can create an armada so damn fast, no one will know where it came from

 

malachor v has the history. powerful in the darkside, like the star forge, but with a sith academy. knowlegde is power. and with that power you can destroy everything.

 

i dont think i can choose.

[Reven of Earth]

Starforge was so much better than malacor v. KOTOR2 overall was just too easy. The starforge offered more challenges, or at least harder ones, which made it more interesting.

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

If Kotor's fighting system was completly real-time and not a mix between turns and attacks, SF would have been awesome, since the sheer number of troops makes it really hard.

 

I vote SF. Malachor wasn't as epic.

 

EDIT: and there wasn't any awesome battle scene in outer space, coupled with incredible music, cutscenes and a general big explosion (which unfortunatly looked like crap)

Edited April 16, 2007 by WILL THE ALMIGHTY

[jwhitsta]

malachor was a really good idea but felt really rushed and hollow. could have been great. The star forge was better fleshed out.