I got scolded by Serafen for trying to pressure Vatnir to join us. :'(

I was able to convince him by assuring him that it was a temporary arrangement. I don't think it gives you a disposition hit if you go that route (?)

 

I also selected the benevolent "you need to help your people" line with Vatnir beforehand; not sure if that makes any difference.

Edited August 3, 20187 yr by Purudaya

I did the same as Purudaya. Alternatively, you can kick Serafen out of your party and take Ydwin instead

I wanted that extra dialogue. Sorry Serafen.

Edited August 3, 20187 yr by anathanielh

That's good to know! Thank you!

 

I suspected that was the case, *but* the Serafen line thoroughly guilted me out of it. I already felt uncomfortable pressuring Vatnir and then Serafen basically pointed out I'm forcing him into something in his Serafen way and I bailed.

 

I might go that route on my next playthrough anyways. Like a hypocrite.

Did the "It's temporary" too.

Hey, I killed Crookspur. I can take one slave in return for saving all, right? Doesn't make me a bad person now, does it?

...

Does it?

 

(And then not use him since I want to keep Xoti around and 2 priests is a total waste)

Edited August 3, 20187 yr by Hassat Hunter

There is something wrong about companion reputation in BoW. When I blame Waidwen and Eothas since They attacked Dyrwood, then I get anti-eothasians from Eder.

There is something wrong about companion reputation in BoW. When I blame Waidwen and Eothas since They attacked Dyrwood, then I get anti-eothasians from Eder.

Probably a bug because normally that would fit. But because of Eder's backgrounds, blanket rep changes for that made the whole thing wonky.

Didn't have that problem myself, went with my POE1 team Aloth, Eder and Pallagenia, plus Maia & Stinkfeathers.