Game ratings from Gamespot mean nothing, nor would any from any site that also tries to sell games. I more inclined to take a rating from G4 as a reference point then I am from most places, but then again thats all it is, someone or several people's opinion, nothing definite. Personally when judging K2 from 1 to 10 I'd have to start at 5 right off the bat, 'cause it seemed to be no more then half finished, plot wise, and too me thats the bigger part of an RPG. Adding in a very immersing start to the game and some cool new features and the game is probaly around a 7 but thats being pretty generous.