Pallegina says my treatment of people speaks poorly of my character (Spoiler Warning!)

[Mygaffer]

Does anyone know why she said this? My character isn't evil. Is this based on reputations? My character is kind of all over the place, for instance benevolence is 4 but cruel is at 2.

 

Any insight would be appreciated. Also, does this low opinion of me have any impact on her personal quest or other interactions with my character?

[Boeroer]

It's because you have a cruel reputation. That you also have benevolent 4 doesn't matter in this case. The game only checks if you are (especially) cruel or not.

[scythesong]

As a general rule if you have opposing predispositions (ie, benevolent and cruel) that are both relevant to a particular dialog check, the game favors the negative one (cruel, in this case).

Edited May 25, 2017 by scythesong