Does anyone know why she said this? My character isn't evil. Is this based on reputations? My character is kind of all over the place, for instance benevolence is 4 but cruel is at 2.

 

Any insight would be appreciated. Also, does this low opinion of me have any impact on her personal quest or other interactions with my character?

It's because you have a cruel reputation. That you also have benevolent 4 doesn't matter in this case. The game only checks if you are (especially) cruel or not.

As a general rule if you have opposing predispositions (ie, benevolent and cruel) that are both relevant to a particular dialog check, the game favors the negative one (cruel, in this case).

Edited May 25, 20178 yr by scythesong