To be completely honest, I've never much cared for 'evil' alignment in games, because I've yet to play a game where the evil path hasn't been way over the top. Though I guess the same can be said of 'good' alignment too. Usually, when I try and play evil, I completely ignore most of the immoral dialogue in favor of appearing as a good guy, having my name chanted by orphans and maidens, and generally being a swell guy; at least, a swell guy up until the end of the game where I gib my party and ascend to Godhood and take over the world. So like previous posters have stated, I'd much prefer a bit of subtlety when it comes to being an evil mastermind rather than the 'I'm going to kick that puppy, set it on fire, and then hurl it at small children because I'm evil and my mother didn't hug me enough.'