I took about a ~6 month break from PoE ... recently started playing again to try out WM2 content.  I rolled up a Priest with Eothas background.

 

I have to say - some of the dialogue options in Act 1 were emotionally very satisfying - the temple of Eothas, Raedric.  In particular, the payoff at Raedric's Hold was money in the bank.  

My impressions were completely different. Especially dialogues with Eder and Durance were deal-breakers for me - it should be very meaningful for those relations that you are Eothasian priest, and it is just ignored. Don't know why there is an option to be a priest of Eothas in the game. Doesn't really make sense.