I'm trying to unlock achievements for Berath's Blessing for a second playthrough (not enjoying my MC in my current one), and wanted to know the easiest island to unlock the Making Your Mark achievement.

Any recommendations?

The one to the southwest with the cannibals didn't give me a whole lot of trouble. 

 

Make sure to hit the shops in Port Maje so you can make your alotted # of bombs/potions. 

Alright, thanks! ^^

You don't need to clean Island to name it. Found out that on Ancient Fampyr Island. Went in cave, decided i can't win, got out and name Island poped out. 

You don't need to clean Island to name it. Found out that on Ancient Fampyr Island. Went in cave, decided i can't win, got out and name Island poped out. 

 

Give it a nice name and imagine all the fools who will go there to visit.