Counterclockwise.
I get Randy to say his success message and the mini-game keeps going. Sometimes a few seconds and then it fails or one time it was about five or so seconds afterwards and then fail. Again, it seems like it doesn't recognize when to "stop". This morning I kept trying for UP TO AN HOUR and same thing... it's not going to Phase 3 like it should and I've seen on numerous videos. Also, is the music supposed to change tempo?
Again, even in Phase 1 I hit down on the left stick to stick the needle and it doesn't register AT ALL. I tried it with three controllers and it's the same way. Left stick controls are just wonky and it doesn't seem like it's only on the 360 version but on the PS3 and PC versions as well.