I really loved this game! The story, characters, world building, the art and game play is really top notch! Personally I prefer story, characters and world exploring in my games.
But it is true it was short. I got through all quests I could find with plenty of exploring within a long weekend and was surprised that the end was really the end of the game and not just of an Act.
On the one hand I liked that this was a shorter game I could actually finish and not something that takes to long so that RL interrupts it and makes jumping in again at a later point much more difficult. (I still have to finish the last DLC of Witcher 3 at some point...)
But on the other hand it still left me with the need for more, which is pretty much the same feeling I have after finishing a good book. I wish this game is just the start of a longer series of games with a continued story like Mass Effect.