Yes,I have to admit that it all sounds very weird.
There have been many games that are plagued with AI,graphical,poor framerate etc issues but since the production values are top notch,they somehow dismiss them all and give them a high score.
It seems ppl are way too stupid these days to understand a game that has skill based shooting. Most of the reviews seem to have one thing in common and that is wondering why they can't hit when their skill for the weapon is low.
This I assume stems from borderlands where you also have skills for weapons,but it doesn't affect the hit rating...iirc.
I guess they were expecting a new gears of war/splinter cell...
It's hard to keep faith in the gaming industry when good games get slandered and games like fps shooter 5000 gets all the praises for having gory executions and over the top bloom in it.