I chose Gabriel for the second playthrough in a row but decided to give myself some scars and some longer hair, so I know what I'm doing now that I got the systems and mechanics down. Not that there's new game+ but my fingers can only be crossed for so long, but still it's whatever and I enjoy fresh playthroughs.
But for a female playthrough I'm gonna go with Raquel, since it's from another Obsidian game and I enjoy rare names.