The biggest issue I´ve always had with pillars 1 was the ammount of "obligatory" items required to pass at least most statchecks, wether they were in scripted actions or dialogs.
You were punished by the game, if you chose different than an item with +3 or +4 attributebonus.
Whats even worse, those items were rarely worth the effort, since they both exhibited useless or even downgrading second enchantments (speedpenality or spellbound) and occupy itemslots better used on other items/effects (bonus spells for example).
However what makes these items so terrible is the fact that they have little to no alternatives.
The player cannot enchant items with a +4 boost to any stat.
They cannot anything except armor, weapons and shields to begin with (so no headgear, rings, etc.).
I wish Obsidian would remove this issue in upcoming games (probably to late for POE2 now) or at least not make matters worse as with the white march dlcs (I HATE those rings +4)
As I can see it they could:
1 Add a wider variety of items with the higest available attribute-bonus
2 Making all attribute-enchantments usable (as an option for crafting) to the players
3 Implementing bonus attributepoints as a part of characterdevelopement
The last option could be done either by granting points upon level-up (easy way, but unpersonal) or by rewarding points for progressing the characters reputation.
As for the last mentioned option, let me explain.
Pillars 1 had 10 reputations/allignments, always in opposing pairs (benevolent/cruel, diplomatic/aggressiv, clever/stoic, passionate/rational and honest/deceptive)
Each of them maxed out (to my knowledge) at 4.
If each reputation grants boni to an attribute that seems logical for it (aggressive->might, benevolent->perception, clever->intelligence) based on its own progress and countered by its oposite, the players would be both rewarded and supported for their chosen playstyle.
Example1: 4 Benevolent/ 0 Cruel -> +4 Perception/ 0 Might
Example2: 4 Ben/ 1 Cr -> +3P/+1M
Example3/4:2 Ben/ 2 Cr OR 3 Ben/ 3Cr OR 4 Ben/ 3Cr -> +2P/+2M for ambivalente personality
etc.
What is your opinion on the subject?