Hallina

IF Revan and/or Exile are in KIII (which I think they should be...Well, Revan at least, after the Carth scene as LSF) I think the game should just intuit through the PC, what they played Revan/Exile as...Of course this could get rather difficult, whatnot... But the options for deciding the Revan character in KII were pretty good, at least decently worked into te dialogue...There's no reason why they can't be worked in that same way in KIII. I think it should be up to the player to decide, but not quite as obvious as having something before the beginning of the game where you decide which is which...That sort of doesn't make it seem very natural to me. If it was decided in dialogue before you meet Revan/Exile, then it would be rather simple to work in. Of course this could all be for noting, and maybe we will only hear of Revan/Exile as we play our own distinct storyline That might be allright, as well, like the game deciding (and acknowledging) that trying to sort out the intricacies of LSF, LSM, DSF, DSM, etc is WAY too har,d and just abandoning the whole thing

Hi all! I was 'googling' and found this topic, and I HAD to register just to vote, if only to defend the lovely Atton. I'm glad I found this board, however, and I look forward to discussing KotOR II on here. Anyway, back on topic Like most others, I had a hard time deciding between Atton and Carth...for about 2 seconds. I loved Carth, but he was so easy to make fall in love with your character. I found Atton a bit harder, for some reason I couldn't gain enough influence to really get into his character the first time I played (that gave me a great reason to play again, so who's complaining?). I love that he's a 'bad' boy though. Carth was sweet, but just a little too nice. Atton represents what KotOR II as a whole is, for me: a slightly edgier, more sarcastic, less saccharine-sweet version of the first game. Exile has more sarcastic lines, and simply being 'good' wont get you in good with some characters, so it provides more challenges, I think. So - I voted for Atton...Its almost a dead tie, which is the way it should be I think, I still have a crush on Carth, despite KII, so I don't think I really want either one to come out on top!