I've seen a few posts here & elsewhere on this topic - but no real solution. How can I get the blade back? I gave tit to him just after

defeating the rogue forge knights

but there was no dialogue indicating that the sword was ready. So I waited. And waited. And waited. Still nuttin'. Any advice would be appreciated.

Edited May 5, 201510 yr by earthwulf

So I loaded in an old save and tried the turn in again... you can only get credit for it (and get the blade) if Dunstan is actually at his forge. If he's chillin' with Clyvver, you don't get anything at all.

This old bug, that seems to have been reported many times in this forum, still exists in the current version.  Started my game with 3.02, and when I turned in to Dunstan while he was in Clyver's room, I now have the quest stuck in my log and he won't ever give me the weapon.