I sat on the fence for a while when AP came out and the reviews were all over the place. I had been looking forward to AP but then I wasn't so sure about it, given Obsidian's two previous titles that are a bit of a mixed bag I was very cyinal. In the end I caved and bought a copy.
And so far I've enjoyed myself playing AP though like KotOR II and NWN2 before it, it has it's share of faults that I'll learn to live with.