I've finished the game on Lightside as a male (without making any of my party into Jedi for some reason; apparently I was just one conversation away on most of 'em, and had enough influence, but just never followed through... grrr...). Now I'm playing it through on Darkside as a female just to see the differences. And, yes, I feel very, very guilty... (That poor dancer; I keep collecting her tips just for fun. I don't really need the money. I'm just so... so... bad...)
Anyways, I've finished Dantooine and Nar Shadda, and Atton and Bao Dur are both dark Jedi now. Kreia and Visas are already Jedi. And G0T0, HK, Hanharr, and my little T3 unit cannot become Jedi. So that just leaves Disciple...
When I first picked him up on Dantooine, I kept the initial conversation very short. I kept reloading and saving, and no matter which option I chose I lost Influence with him. (Is it because I was thoroughly Darkside when I met him, I wonder?) Then I continued the conversation and kept gaining Influence. I'm at the point where I can offer to make him a Jedi, but he declines (and says something about it may never happen). He won't tell me what his problem is with the Jedi, either.
So I'm trying desperately to gain just another notch or two of Influence with the guy, because I just can't seem to make it happen through conversation. Oh, I can certainly lose Influence with the guy; I just have to slaughter some poor fool who gets in my way for no good reason. But performing acts of charity all over Nar Shadda doesn't seem to impress him at all.
Any suggestions? I suppose it doesn't matter a whole lot; I've got a full roster of characters to play with. But I just wanted to train up everyone possible in the party for fun...
Thanks for the advice & spoilers!
-- Scott