ridiculous-fosterman

I'm planning my first playthrough of PoE1, but I can't decide on class for my character. I love to roleplay in this type of games and I would like to roleplay a holy warrior of some sort (think Beric Dondarrion or Thoros of Myr from Game of Thrones). Someone who used to be a horrible person and his history is scarred by violence and war, but now wants have a second chance and redeem himself, help others and do good in the world. Also deeply religious, but not overzealous. From what I can see, my only choices are Paladin or Priest. I dislike playing solely ranged/caster characters, so ideal would be melee (sword and shield/two handed weapon) with combinations of spells, heals and buffs. I'm aware of paladin orders and priest's chosen deity, but I'm not so knowledgeable about the lore. I think Kind Wayfarers or The Shieldbearers of St. Elcga for Paladin and Priest of Eothas should work, but as I'm saying, I don't really know. For PoE2 I plan to multiclass these two classes, however I don't know which of these classes would be more fitting for PoE1, so any tips regarding to this would be appreciated, thank you!