I know my opinions are things people have probably said before but, being almost brand new to the whole gaming thing I would just like to put in my two cents. ^.^ I honestly don't play many games, KotOR was my first, and KotOR II my second, but I've been doing rp online, D&D and live action for years so that's more my area of interest. In some eyes that may discredit my opinion but I think it's just as important to have the pov from both avid gamers and newbies alike. ^.^;
The first game was a WONDERFUL rp experience, and the second was much better graphics wise. I was sad that the second's rp was nowhere near as entertaining however, concidering this is an rpg. I think if Bioware and Obsidian were to work together they may very well come up with one of the best games ever made.
Personally, I'd really prefer to play Revan again. The setup of the first game allowed the player to become much more attatched to thier pc and I want to play the resolution of her story myself. Also to play with some of the characters from both of the previous games would be good (like Carth, Bastila, Mandalore, HK, etc.) I know some people think Revan (or the Exile) would be too powerful but if you're fighting the True Sith in the unknown regions you wouldn't be. And I would be very dissappointed if they didn't bring her story to a good close/resolution.
There's a petition for this if you agree, any and all are welcome to sign. (It's not my petition however, I don't presume to take any credit for it.)
http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?012387
/mytwocents