It never ceases to amaze me how many people claim to have indepth knowledge of sword fighting techniques...I especially like those who try to claim that they're masters of a style that only ONE Japanese Samurai in history has ever been known to do decently in warfare. And that kind of the what the real test is, isn't it? Theory is great but unless you have any evidence its just heresy without proof.
I love armchair generals. Honestly guys, get a clue. You aren't out there fighting everyday, I doubt that a single one of you has ever been in a fight where you actually USED swords....how is your opinion any different from that of the devs?
Oh...and don't try to tell me that you're a master because you're in some kind of 're-enactment' society...all that really says to me that you waste your time in the park sitting out there messing around in mail and plate armor. What you're doing is acting, and how many people take actors as serious references for history? Its like an actor from ER claiming that he can give advice as a doctor based off his experience on the show. Fencing is great, but how many two hand weapon fencers do you see? None? Yeah....Sitting in a room messing with swords is far different than living a life where you know that eventually you're going to be a fight to the death against another person. Its just so different that this conversation is effectively worthless.