Bug #9830105849 - Warden of Runes vs Wand of Scorching Ray

[Vinceicarus]

Mountain Peak

Normal

iPad

Merisel has Constitution roll (d6), rolls a 4 against a 14 diff for Warden of Runes. Soaks 1 electricity damage by revealing seheldon ring.

 

Next turn, combat, Wand of Scorching Ray cannot be selected to play (no lock or nothing, just not blue and cannot be used). 

 

Warden of Runes immune to Cold and Electricy not Fire.

Edited September 16, 2017 by Vinceicarus

[Vinceicarus]

Nevermind, just learnt about the single item thingy. Not a bug You can close this. 

[Jenceslav]

I would disagree that the 1-card-of-one-type rule is responsible. First, the damage is done before the combat check, so it is a different time. Other thing would be if you tried to prevent damage from failing combat check. Then the rule would kick in. Secondly, the ring has a clause of "you may use another item on this check"...

Seems like a proper bug.

[Hannibal_PJV]

Before the encounter, During the check, and After the encounter are three separate instances of damage in this case, and so can have something reduce the damage to each one.

 

Note that because they are separate instances, you can play an armor on each one, or an item on each one, or a spell on each one, as it does not kick in the 'one card of each type per person per step/check' rule.

 

But when you asseble you combat and chose the skill untill the damage phase Are one instances so between those the one card of its type limit aply.

[Ethics Gradient]

I would disagree that the 1-card-of-one-type rule is responsible. First, the damage is done before the combat check, so it is a different time. Other thing would be if you tried to prevent damage from failing combat check. Then the rule would kick in. Secondly, the ring has a clause of "you may use another item on this check"...

Seems like a proper bug.

 

Yeah.  Totally a bug. "Before you act" issues pop up from time to time and have been periodically fixed over the last year.

 

From the "outside" it is difficult to guess if the problem is with individual cards, or the game engine itself.  But since it feels like BYA problems have been addressed on a case-by-case basis, and the remaining issues appear concentrated in AD5/AD6/ADG1, it is probably a logic bug with specific cards.