Jump to content

Welcome to Obsidian Forum Community
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Factions comparison

RDC VTC Huana Príncipi

  • Please log in to reply
37 replies to this topic

Poll: Fractions in Deadfire (187 member(s) have cast votes)

What fraction will you choose?

  1. Royal Deadfire Company (30 votes [14.08%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 14.08%

  2. Vailian Trading Company (59 votes [27.70%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 27.70%

  3. Principi (34 votes [15.96%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 15.96%

  4. Huana (42 votes [19.72%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 19.72%

  5. No fraction - I'm a dissident (48 votes [22.54%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 22.54%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#21
Celan

Celan

    (3) Conjurer

  • Members
  • 139 posts
  • Pillars of Eternity Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer
VTC is the one that might actually make progress on that front out of literally every faction in the world we know of (including everyone inthe Dyrwood). 

Except their track record is pretty dismal.

 

Anyway, I hated all of them by the end and (cue Sonatra music) did it my way.



#22
jtbehnke

jtbehnke

    (3) Conjurer

  • Members
  • 122 posts
  • Location:Hastings, MN

My vote goes to the Huana.  They may have problems, but the Deadfire is their home, and the other factions are looking to exploit them and their resources.  Colonialism and imperialism are nasty things, and I don't want to aid and abet them.


  • Tick, SerenityHarkness and quaggan like this

#23
CrazyL3opold

CrazyL3opold

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 16 posts
  • Location:Germany
  • Deadfire Backer

Everyone who chooses the Huana is an enemy of mine. They are the faction with the least morally acceptable quest to do... I would never do anything that is bad for Castol! He's one of the nicest and friendliest persons hanging around in the Deadfire and that b**** of Onekaza is simply to weak to do anything at least a bit ok. Caste system... Lose of power... etc... All other factions are ok ^^ But I like Vailians and Furrante most!



#24
Tick

Tick

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 528 posts

Everyone who chooses the Huana is an enemy of mine. They are the faction with the least morally acceptable quest to do... I would never do anything that is bad for Castol! He's one of the nicest and friendliest persons hanging around in the Deadfire and that b**** of Onekaza is simply to weak to do anything at least a bit ok. Caste system... Lose of power... etc... All other factions are ok ^^ But I like Vailians and Furrante most!

 

Some strong feelings there lol.

 

I sided with the Huana because I think the culture has strengths and the government wants to do right by its people, and I don't feel comfortable with helping a foreign power forcibly take over another group of people, potentially ruin that group of people's lives, and take away their culture and identity.   It gives the group no choice in the matter, either.

 

I don't think the caste system is fantastic, but when it works properly, it means everyone is taken care of.  Which I think is a huge strength compared to some societies that just let people fall in the cracks and rot there.  I couldn't go Huana if I knew that the problem with the Gullet and Watershapers wasn't fixed, but those are fixable issues.

 

I do love Castol and I was horrified when I realized that was the Huana route, but there are ways to go the Huana route without ruining his life, so that's the route I went.


  • Ger, CrazyL3opold, SerenityHarkness and 2 others like this

#25
Mari

Mari

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 36 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

I ended up going my own way.

 

I was a bit conflicted at first since I knew going solo was the chaotic ****ty ending, so I did consider maybe just joining one of the factions. In the end, I disliked all of them, and the choice was kinda made for me because all the ending quests require you to become a terrorist who blows up buildings and/or kills major political figures! I really couldn't come up with a in-game reason my character would agree to any of this. I'm just here to help the poor, make some money, and to stop a God, not play terrorist for some **** who cant even cooperate long enough to deal with a common crisis. 

 

I know everyone likes the VTC cuz of the animancy, but I found them to be the worst of the bunch. They sound like the personification of every real world corporation willing to kill us all so they could strip mine natural resources for profit. Like, luminous adra seems pretty vital, what with housing souls and all that, and these people wanna mine it all up and snort it???? Not to mention that they have no issue with slavery and Castor himself was dealing in slaves. I think their "profit over anything else" mentality is dangerous and it wouldn't take very much before they depleted all natural adra and started trying to make their own by killing slaves (which, as indicated by the letter you find, one of their research team was already contemplating). I had Eothas inspire mortals so I feel like the animancers will be able to figure out the Wheel even without these crazy bastards.

Out of all of them, I thought the RDC where the least of the evils and the most "gray" faction. I still cant make up my mind about it. On one hand, colonialism is undeniably bad and the RDC are arrogant imperialists who think they know best. On the other, if your culture involves oppressing people and intentionally keeping them in abject poverty where they starve, am I really gonna shed a tear if another group shows up and assimilates you? Buuuuut the RDC attacked me when I said I wasn't going to assassinate the Queen for them so I had to kill them all. Oh well.    

The Huana have an abhorrent caste system, but I feel the most sympathetic for them cuz they are the only faction where we got to meet civilians/regular people. The RDC is military, VTC is a corporation, but a lot of the Huana we meet are just villagers who are getting screwed over on all sides. I tried to help the villagers as much as I could, but again, no way am I doing the dirty work for a society that thinks its fine to intentionally keep a whole group of people in poverty. 

 

As for the principi, they are a bunch of loosely organized pirates so I didn't even consider them. I killed the old man and replaced him with Aedlys cuz she was anti-slavery and I liked her. Plus, she was helping me smuggle food to the Roparu.


Edited by Mari, 25 June 2018 - 11:30 AM.

  • Tick and Kian like this

#26
CrazyL3opold

CrazyL3opold

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 16 posts
  • Location:Germany
  • Deadfire Backer

 

Everyone who chooses the Huana is an enemy of mine. They are the faction with the least morally acceptable quest to do... I would never do anything that is bad for Castol! He's one of the nicest and friendliest persons hanging around in the Deadfire and that b**** of Onekaza is simply to weak to do anything at least a bit ok. Caste system... Lose of power... etc... All other factions are ok ^^ But I like Vailians and Furrante most!

 

Some strong feelings there lol.

 

I sided with the Huana because I think the culture has strengths and the government wants to do right by its people, and I don't feel comfortable with helping a foreign power forcibly take over another group of people, potentially ruin that group of people's lives, and take away their culture and identity.   It gives the group no choice in the matter, either.

 

I don't think the caste system is fantastic, but when it works properly, it means everyone is taken care of.  Which I think is a huge strength compared to some societies that just let people fall in the cracks and rot there.  I couldn't go Huana if I knew that the problem with the Gullet and Watershapers wasn't fixed, but those are fixable issues.

 

I do love Castol and I was horrified when I realized that was the Huana route, but there are ways to go the Huana route without ruining his life, so that's the route I went.

How does this work? I could either ruin Castol OR get into conflict with the Huana. How did you avoid this?


  • Tick likes this

#27
Tick

Tick

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 528 posts

 

 

Everyone who chooses the Huana is an enemy of mine. They are the faction with the least morally acceptable quest to do... I would never do anything that is bad for Castol! He's one of the nicest and friendliest persons hanging around in the Deadfire and that b**** of Onekaza is simply to weak to do anything at least a bit ok. Caste system... Lose of power... etc... All other factions are ok ^^ But I like Vailians and Furrante most!

 

Some strong feelings there lol.

 

I sided with the Huana because I think the culture has strengths and the government wants to do right by its people, and I don't feel comfortable with helping a foreign power forcibly take over another group of people, potentially ruin that group of people's lives, and take away their culture and identity.   It gives the group no choice in the matter, either.

 

I don't think the caste system is fantastic, but when it works properly, it means everyone is taken care of.  Which I think is a huge strength compared to some societies that just let people fall in the cracks and rot there.  I couldn't go Huana if I knew that the problem with the Gullet and Watershapers wasn't fixed, but those are fixable issues.

 

I do love Castol and I was horrified when I realized that was the Huana route, but there are ways to go the Huana route without ruining his life, so that's the route I went.

How does this work? I could either ruin Castol OR get into conflict with the Huana. How did you avoid this?

 

 

 

Before even talking to the Onekaza, I went to the Hazanui and told her I'd side with the Rauatai.  When she told me that required killing the Onekaza (and potentially others), I eventually had to back out and say "I can't do this." 

 

The Hazanui can't let you leave after telling you all that, knowing you're not okay with it, so she tries to kill you.  You have to kill her and everyone in the Rauatai headquarters (that finds you) in self defense to escape, which indirectly lands a huge blow to the Rauatai.  If you go to the Onekaza after that, she's happy with that and doesn't make you do her nasty sidequest.  So long as you helped Castol out in his hearings, he'll be basically fine in the endings.  He gets to stay in the Deadfire Archipelago in a smaller role to research animancy, which he likes.  He even saves Pallegina from getting messed up by the Huana ending.

 

It still sucks because you have to kill the Hazanui and anyone that finds you in the HQ, which I didn't want to do, but out of all the awful ways to get one of the better endings, it's one of the least awful.


  • Carmir, Rheios, Incendax and 2 others like this

#28
Ger

Ger

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 14 posts

I chose Huana because they seemed to be the "right" choice out of the options.  Honestly, the only choice for me. In a fantasy game, I get to let the native Huana keep their lands and advance naturally on their own (including re-acclimation of Ukaizo) rather than be over-run with outsiders and their own selfish desires.

I also had to slaughter the RDC because I chose the druids in Sayuka, so Castol was in the clear.

The ending slides, including improvements for the Roparu, made me very happy with my choice.  For a while, it didn't seem like there was a "good guy" choice.  There was.


  • Tick likes this

#29
uuuhhii

uuuhhii

    (4) Theurgist

  • Members
  • 363 posts

no faction doesn't make one dissident

anti faction are



#30
Griselune

Griselune

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 9 posts

RDC for me. Their ending is the best for me, as they disregard individuals for the greater good.

 

What are a few assassinations if it brings progress (hate the Huana caste system), safety (bye bye dirty pirates) and freedom (bye bye evil slavers). 

 

After joining them, ending slides were like:

 

Spoiler

 

And all of this, just by

 

Spoiler

 

That is just good politics. 


  • Parasol_Syndicate likes this

#31
1TTFFSSE

1TTFFSSE

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 527 posts

Valians - Athens

RDC - Sparta

Huana - Persia

Principi - Sicilians ?  :w00t:


Edited by 1TTFFSSE, 03 July 2018 - 02:31 PM.


#32
Anmar

Anmar

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 25 posts
  • Location:Sydney
  • Deadfire Silver Backer
  • Fig Backer
  • Black Isle Bastard!

I'm with DaggerKnight.  For different reasons, I tried to make a deal with and got trapped and couldn't get back to my ship. Not without a cheat code at least and I would rather die miserably a failure than die gallantly a cheat.

 so I say

Death to the Royal Deadfire Company!

Death to the RDC!

 

And long may you dwell there.

 

(I sound like the US military on a rant, I'm not, I'm just a sad ol sack who only has words left)



#33
hermamora

hermamora

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 27 posts

1. At first I thought I'll choose Principi because Doemenels were my choice in POE1 and in every game I prefer to stick with ambiguous and gray fractions. But pirates in PIE turned out to be disgusting thugs much like in real life which isn't very interesting. 

2. Huana is the worst, I can't understand how someone could choose those weak and barbaric people with no future, if Roman empire never expanded Europe would have no modern culture and science. Sadly, western propaganda works even now with "white man's burden" and people will choose to preserve barbaric traditions just because "it's their home" instead of eliminating caste system and famine. And it's not like those retrogrades could keep their position for a long time, Ruautai will conquer them anyway. 

3. Speaking of Ruautai, politically and logically RDC is the best option for the Deadfire because they'll continue expansion no matter what you choose. They have most advanced military complex in the world and it's only naive to think one burned warehouse will stop them for a long time. They're ruthless, patient and in dire need of new colonies for their people so it's not the end. Also they're basically one nation with Huana so it's not like they'll slaughter natives. 

4. Vailians are the best for main plot, they're the only one who interesting in animancy so it's only logical if Watcher will choose to support them. They'll help to resolve his (her?) personal issues and globally VTC are so much better than other choices.

5. Going by yourself is... how is that even an option? I mean it's great we can opt to go alone but it's so unrealistic and sad our main hero tried to solve global problem without any support and even if he succeed it will be descent in the chaos for the islands. 



#34
Parasol_Syndicate

Parasol_Syndicate

    (4) Theurgist

  • Members
  • 268 posts
  • Location:Lonestar Kingdom

RDC for me. Their ending is the best for me, as they disregard individuals for the greater good.

 

What are a few assassinations if it brings progress (hate the Huana caste system), safety (bye bye dirty pirates) and freedom (bye bye evil slavers). 

 

 

That is just good politics. 

 

Accurate assessment.

Assassinations are horrible. 
Wars are horrible AND senseless. 

 

A major disconnect of the RP and G aspects of deadfire was the RDCs announcement that there has to be a coup...

...and the fact that YOU have to do it. It just felt so gamey and artificial. The choice should have come down to "Interfere or don't."


Edited by Parasol_Syndicate, 12 July 2018 - 12:16 PM.


#35
Rheios

Rheios

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 59 posts
  • Pillars of Eternity Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

I didn't vote because I'm going to end up picking them all on different characters, but on my first character - who was a Death Godlike Priest of Berath - I ended up going Huana. They seemed like they had the greatest respect for the dieties - something my character happily extended to Berath and was willing to extend to other deities when they had their heads out of their own ass - and were a native culture on the verge of their first step into the next phase of a society. They had declined and now had the ability to rise but had to change in response to surrounding pressures. So whenever I could I pointed out their hypocrisy and how their current system made them weak and got them to do the right thing and help the Gullet themselves. He was pretty neutral to all the other factions and ended up on good terms with everybody even after the espionage, except for the Princip which he decimated as he felt they had stagnated regardless of leader. Although he seriously didn't like the VTC mining the glowing Adra. They were part of the soul wheel, he knew it, and he hated to think of soul energy used that way. He repaired the Poko adra because of that but never turned in the quest. 

Sadly I have no idea how things turned out because that character fought Eothas because he'd been tasked with stopping him and there's no 'please listen to reason and keep a working system working, you giant ****ing manchild' option.

EDIT: I guess he wasn't "tasked" with stopping Eothas. He certainly still wanted to though. And frankly the 'talk  to him' pep-talks misled a bit...


Edited by Rheios, 31 July 2018 - 06:56 PM.

  • Tick likes this

#36
Suen

Suen

    (4) Theurgist

  • Members
  • 399 posts
  • Pillars of Eternity Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

No fraction. I refuse to compromise my integerity. 
 

I'll escort myself out.


  • bugarup and Hawke64 like this

#37
Incendax

Incendax

    (3) Conjurer

  • Members
  • 165 posts

...and the fact that YOU have to do it. It just felt so gamey and artificial. The choice should have come down to "Interfere or don't."

Would have been fine if they sent you to Queen’s Berth as the distraction. It was definitely bizarre they trusted you with the actual assassination. Unless they didn’t expect you to succeed and it was just win-win for them either way.
  • Parasol_Syndicate likes this

#38
Pigeonheart

Pigeonheart

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 8 posts

The Vailian ending is my preferred ending too, but not because of some rose tinted outcome outlined in the epilogue slides.  The game gives you a few instances to bring up that they are ultimately using souls to fuel their technological advances, and this is usually brushed off as a simpleton's understanding of the issue without much defence beyond 'poo-pooing'.

 

As an inequal society chasing profit I really hope they become dependant on adra fuel for everything, industry, lifestyle, transport.  I want to see what happens when their use of souls outstrips supply and what happens when more than just a regional zone begins to experience Waidwen's Legacy like symptoms.

 

Giving any faction control of the wheel is certainly interesting.  If you had that kind of power would you be inclined to preferentially supply strong (or even just available) souls to your faction?  What if  they discover Thaos like immortality... who gets access to that?







Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: RDC, VTC, Huana, Príncipi

1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users