Here's a run down of my last PotD run through, with a non-optimized party.
Most Enemies Defeated: Chanter (35)
Most Total Damage Done: BB Wizard (4891)
High Single Target Damage: BB Wizard (46)
Most Crits: Ranger (31)
Most Hits: BB Priest (697)
Most Damage Taken: Fighter (4021)
Most Times Knocked Out: Fighter (4)
Ranger (Tank) - Coastal Aumaua, pet is a wolf.
Fighter (DPS Tank), human.
Paladin (Off-tank, support DPS) Moon Godlike of Darcozzi Paladini
Chanter (Ranged Summoner/DPS) Coastal Aumaua
Fun note, Wizard had the highest damage for the party, but only by 18 points.
While the other tanks out-damage the ranger, the ranger doesn't have any epic weapons like they do. Give my ranger an on crit: prone weapon that also has +12 accuracy and you're looking at a game changer. It's also worth noting that he uses a sword and shield, not a mace (which is by far superior), whereas the other tanks are using a 2H weapon. I am confident that no other sword and board user can reached that kind of damage in melee while still being extremely durable and reliable.
Also... I noticed this, and I am hesitant to share it, but... I did find a possible bug with Swift Aim and Cautious Attack.
Edited by Sock, 23 March 2015 - 09:08 PM.