If you didn't rate items by something silly like S-Tier etc your lists might be informative for new players.
So far I have not seen a list full of flaws in the rating, which would not matter if you didn't rate items you haven't even tested.
I decided to post in the armour list, because here the rating is the worst by far.
Not only are the best armours like patinated and blackened rated very low, the reasoning for your S-tier armours is very flawed for Deadfire, "highest dps".
This game has as many people already posted, several pets, that not only reduce the recovery of armor, no the best part is, the heavier the armor, the stronger the pet effect.
Gaining 0.2 seconds recovery between a heavy plate and a light armor is most likely the best result you will get if you ahve decent or even high dex.
Sadly you forgot to mention that armor class is much more potent in Deadfire than it was in Poe 1, having no pen results in a 75%+ damage loss for the enemy.
Moral of the story:
Don't rate items you never tested.
Let alone in a game you either don't fully understand the mechanics or don't care to explain them to the only people who might find your lists helpful: beginners.