Jump to content

Welcome to Obsidian Forum Community
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Critical Hits and Critical Failure...


  • Please log in to reply
34 replies to this topic

#1
Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo

    Vorpal Panzerfaust of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 6002 posts
  • Location:England, This Blessed Plot
  • Xbox Gamertag:MonteCarlo
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Posted Image

Is doing double damage, which is then deflected by a helmet anyway, really the best manner to celebrate the pure awesomeness of rolling '20'? (or whatever the PE version will be).

I think not, my friends! I think not!

Ditto rolling a natural '1' with the buttock-clenching prospect of utter disaster this can herald in a pen and paper game.

Here is the famous Dave Hargrave critical hit and fumble table from Arduin...

Posted Image

So, do you like the idea of critical success and failure being deep, shallow or not represented at all?
  • Nonek, HansKrSG, Osvir and 4 others like this

#2
Gallenger

Gallenger

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 28 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
I think, as far as the cRPG's go, fallout 1-2 had rather good critical hit/miss results with some interesting dialogue added in. I'm personally not a huge fan of massive critical results and like for it to be normalized (much like in 3.5E D&D where you're locked into x2, x3, x4 damage etc). Mainly because the party will receive, in general, many more critical hits than they'll dish out - and if they have massive, and long reaching, in-game penalities, you're only truly hampering the players or robbing them of an interesting encounter because they got incredibly lucky (although a solid normal crit can do the same in some cases).

I also enjoy the fallout critical failure results. Drop weapon, strike yourself, strike unintended target, cripple a limb, break the weapon, lose your ammo, lose AC points due to balance, etc. Because again, as far as the party goes it'll be fairly rare that they manage to roll a 1 at any point and it can add some hilarity and shake up encounters. Again though, only 1-2 of those have massive in-game penalities (broken weapon, crippled limb).
  • Hormalakh likes this

#3
Skapanza

Skapanza

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 16 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
I've always loved the institution of critical hit/failure tables. My gaming group has hatched many home-brewed systems for this in the past, and they've had a number of very interesting and fun to roleplay gaming experiences. When we sit around at the tavern quaffing ale and telling tales, invariably a story about a great crit or a catastrophic fumble comes up.

That being said, as awesome as these are for pen-and-paper gaming, they seem like they would be difficult to carry out in the same manner in a cRPG. If your hand was severed, does your sprite lose a hand? In pen-and-paper games, the DM can provide you with a side quest to get revenge or seek out a scroll of regeneration, or to make a pact with an extra-planar being to restore your injury. It seems like these aspects would be hard to replicate in a cRPG experience.

It would be a lot of fun to have a somewhat reduced version of this, however. Perhaps a severe injury would prove fatal within a certain time frame if medical/magical care isn't found (I'm cribbing from the provided table here, thanks for posting that by the way!). Priests could perhaps call on a favor from their god at some point in the game and be forced to undertake a quest that progresses the aims of their diety in order to repay them. It's certainly an interesting topic. I'd love to see some variation from the typical x2 dmg crit. It seems like it could be a challenge to make part of the game, but perhaps with the existence of stamina/health it could be worked into the combat system.

#4
Nonek

Nonek

    Not of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 1808 posts
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Critical hits smash straight through stamina and deal health damage, critical failures result in stamina damage perhaps?
  • .Leif. likes this

#5
Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo

    Vorpal Panzerfaust of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 6002 posts
  • Location:England, This Blessed Plot
  • Xbox Gamertag:MonteCarlo
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Yes, that could work. The idea of accidentally smashing an NPCs head in appeals, as does insta-chunking a powerful opponent a la the Hargrave table (critical hit plus a 99-00 roll equivalent).

Company of Heroes, although an RTS, does this *very* well. All units have a random crit hit chance that can make for some rare, but fun, moments of awesomeness. Even the lowliest American rifleman can, if he is *very* lucky, take out a lumbering Tiger tank with a sticky bomb.

#6
Skapanza

Skapanza

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 16 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Referring to Nonek's post: I like the idea, but it seems slightly impersonal. When someone chops you with a sword, you aren't injured in your overall being, you're injured at the stump where your left arm used to be. Same idea when an arrow goes through your eye.

The more I think about it, the more I think this could potentially be done in the game, by incorporating injuries into the character sheet. If your arm is chopped, no weapon in that hand. An eye injury might limit your range, give penalties to charisma, spot, search, etc. An injured leg reduces movement speed and dodge.

I think those little touches would do a lot for my feeling of immersion of the game, so I feel like I know where my characters are being hurt, and have my wizard wearing a helmet because he can't afford to lose his other eye. It also could provide some side quests, as the paladin must earn the favor of her diety by protecting a temple from raiders so she can have her arm restored, or the barbarian has to battle the evil in his soul after his sight was restored by the evil priest making a demonic pact on his behalf.

Edited by Skapanza, 28 October 2012 - 06:33 AM.

  • Monte Carlo, Nonek, Osvir and 4 others like this

#7
Nonek

Nonek

    Not of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 1808 posts
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
I would like to have a mechanical hand crafted for my character, rune bound silver or some such.

#8
Christliar

Christliar

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 50 posts
The most glaring problem with this is that crits happen regularly and if every crit injures you severely enough for you to go do a quest to restore that part of your body I see it getting tiresome pretty fast. MAYBE a stat reduction for the duration of the BATTLE, but beyond that it's just tedious.

#9
Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo

    Vorpal Panzerfaust of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 6002 posts
  • Location:England, This Blessed Plot
  • Xbox Gamertag:MonteCarlo
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
^ Hmmm not a number cruncher but a 1% chance of a 1% chance of something happening shouldn't be a too frequent problem. But when it does it's awesome.

#10
Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo

    Vorpal Panzerfaust of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 6002 posts
  • Location:England, This Blessed Plot
  • Xbox Gamertag:MonteCarlo
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer

I would like to have a mechanical hand crafted for my character, rune bound silver or some such.


Just for you, Sir...

http://en.wikipedia....the_Silver_Hand
  • Nonek likes this

#11
Nonek

Nonek

    Not of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 1808 posts
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Wondered if anybody would spot that, reading Knight of Swords at the moment.

#12
Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo

    Vorpal Panzerfaust of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 6002 posts
  • Location:England, This Blessed Plot
  • Xbox Gamertag:MonteCarlo
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Love all of the Elric, Hawkmoon and Corum stuff, especially Hawkmoon.

Any villain who is the Baron of New Croiyden is OK by me.

#13
Skapanza

Skapanza

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 16 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer

The most glaring problem with this is that crits happen regularly and if every crit injures you severely enough for you to go do a quest to restore that part of your body I see it getting tiresome pretty fast. MAYBE a stat reduction for the duration of the BATTLE, but beyond that it's just tedious.


This is definitely a valid concern. Certainly you don't want to see the game experience drastically altered because your three fighter-types take an hour to walk anywhere on their crippled legs. Monte Carlo makes a good point as well though. You can have critical hits that do x2 damage, but a slim chance to have something more serious occur. I think it would heighten the sense of danger and help maintain immersion, as some quality attacks would damage not the imaginary yellow and red stamina/health bars, but actually show up on your character sheet in a meaningful way, and have to be addressed in a way that is both challenging but also rewarding in terms of the storytelling of your character.
  • Pipyui likes this

#14
HereticSaint

HereticSaint

    (3) Conjurer

  • Members
  • 148 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
I absolutely hate the idea of critical failures both on paper and in practice. A real swordsman doesn't swing his sword around into his own torso on average one of of every twenty attacks. He likewise doesn't fling it 50 ft away because he misses his target. I can more reliably swing a sword than that. Even having to roll a one twice in a row on a D20 to get any real dangerous critical failures is still bothersome.

I like critical hits, but I think that chance to crit should be more based on armor than it has traditionally been in the past. AKA: Full Platemail should have an innate critical strike reduction chance that eats a percentage off someones chance to crit. AKA: Archer with 5% chance to crit attacks someone in Full Platemail but Full Platemail has a 80% (or 50, or whatever) reduction in the chance of being critically struck. So now the Archer actually has a 1% chance to critically strike.

#15
AgentOrange

AgentOrange

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 57 posts
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Been replaying Arcanum recently, and it has a rather interesting and deep critical success/failure system. It is tied to the Magick and Technology dichotomy, so that those with Magickal affinity have a higher chance to critically fail when using tech, but tech savvy people will critically fail if their opponent is highly magickal. Obviously this doesn't work for PE, but it would be neat if the critical chances had a calculation process that went behind simple chance - having a higher chance to critically fail when using a a certain weapon against a certain enemy, or when a certain race uses a certain weapon. It has happens far too often in Arcanum though, I see a critical success/failure at least twice per battle. It should happy only once in a every few.

Overall I love the idea of critical hits and failures; some of my fondest memories from Fallout are the situation when a battle was turned in my favor or against me because of them - running out of ammo and managing to puncture an opponents eyes with my hands, or accidentally setting myself on fire when a molotov explodes prematurely.

Edited by AgentOrange, 28 October 2012 - 07:18 PM.

  • Hormalakh likes this

#16
Hassat Hunter

Hassat Hunter

    Royal Bug Catcher of the Obsidian Order

  • Members
  • 4912 posts
  • Location:Out there, somewhere...
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
I probably think something akin to the Drakensang system would be best. However without the massive damage, just with crits.

In that it can add a permanent injury, which can only be healed with the proper items afterwards (bandage, healing).

Since injuries happen often in Drakensang those items where plenty available. Too much. They could be rarer in PE, and thus the effect might be harder to take/take up a much more precious and costly item in your inventory.

So criticals would still be debilitating. Not just for that battle, but maybe more to come if you don't treat them. However nothing like cut off hands, just lowered skills, or another penalty if you acquire 2 or 3 (or more).

#17
KaineParker

KaineParker

    (11) Wizard

  • Members
  • 1658 posts
  • Location:Houston, Texas
  • Silver Backer
I like the idea of critical failures, but would like to see them apply to all checks, not just combat. I think Obsidian can come up with some great consequences for critical failures, but I would not like them to be randomized effects.

Critical hits can either do multiplied damage or go straight to HP, and critical success(in regards to saves and checks) can result in various rewards, like a high-quality item when crafting.

#18
Sacred_Path

Sacred_Path

    (9) Sorcerer

  • Members
  • 1283 posts
  • Location:Germany
  • Silver Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Critical hits only if there's also a targeting system, otherwise they don't add much. Critical failures shouldn't be as frequent as in Arcanum plz, the only thing you do on Hard mode is stunning yourself.

#19
Mikaw

Mikaw

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 22 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
Critical hits should go straight to HP, without multiplier. In addition to that, I think that damages applied to hp should be localized (randomly?) and have particular effects depending on the body part : movement penalty for legs, attack penalty for arms for examples... Those kind of injuries heals very slowly. I take exemples based on D&D 3.5 to illutrate this : a character can have an amount of HP equal to his constitution and vitality/stamina based on his class level. In a system like this HP value won't increase or very slowly and will be a pretty low value during all the game. As your character grows in experience and level, he has more and more vitality which give him more chance to avoid being really hurt. Each hit applied directly to HP will have bad consequences for the player, and if he doesn't have any magical healing, such wounds will take days or weeks to fully heal with all the penalty remaining until the healing is complete (1hp/day for example in a d&d based system)

#20
Radres

Radres

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 50 posts
  • Backer
  • Kickstarter Backer
http://forums.obsidi...tional-effects/




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users