OoT was like the 5th Zelda game or something.
Yes but if you take into consideration that the first zelda game didn't have anything but monsters, the second zelda game was RPG-like, the third one is the one that defined the basic Zelda games formula (the Link to the Past) and the forth which is Link's awakening is different, makes OoT the second game that follows the formula and the first 3d zelda game.
Anyway, I think Yatzees' reviews are great. I even liked the PH one (even though I am a Zelda fanboy - and I don't agree with what he said to an extend).
I think OoT was great. That's not the point. I'm as much a Zelda fan as anyone, it's just that I'd like to see the rabid fanboys squirm when someone like Yatzee criticizes their holy, godlike games.